Investment Gains vs. Mortgage Interest


When it comes to deciding whether to invest or pay off a mortgage, various factors come into play. This includes the borrower’s financial condition, the loan’s interest rate, and the individual’s closeness to retirement. Additionally, the alternative of investing that money needs to be considered. It’s critical to balance the potential interest savings of paying off the mortgage sooner against the prospective returns from investing those funds in the market.

The way a mortgage payment impacts your finances splits into interest and principal portions. In the early years, a larger amount of the payment goes towards interest, while in the later years, more is directed towards decreasing the principal. This distribution changes over the loan’s lifetime due to fluctuating loan balance.

Weigh investment and mortgage repayment options
Weigh investment and mortgage repayment options

Deciding to pay off a mortgage early can depend on individual circumstances. For instance, if a borrower has ten years left on a $200,000 mortgage and receives a $120,000 inheritance, they might consider early repayment. The interest saved by this early repayment will depend on various interest rates. For example, at a 3.5% interest rate, early repayment would save $20,270 in interest. However, this only accounts for 17% of the total interest cost for a 30-year loan since the borrower has already paid $103,042 in interest in the first 20 years.

When making financial choices, it’s worth considering if investing a portion or all of your funds would yield more benefits than paying off your mortgage. The opportunity cost, or the interest that could be earned by investing in financial markets, is a key consideration. Evaluating an investment requires looking at the expected return and related risks. The benefits of investments are compounded, considering both the interest earned on the original investment and any accrued interest over time. Remember, this assumes no withdrawals were made during the ten-year period.

By weighing these potential investment returns, you can better grasp the possible advantages of investing your funds instead of paying off your mortgage prematurely.

When you compare the gains from investment to the interest saved by early mortgage repayment, you’ll find different results. If a homeowner invests $100,000 over ten years at a 2% average rate of return, they would earn $22,019, closely matching the $20,270 saved in interest by paying off a 3.5% mortgage. But if the average return rate is 5%, the homeowner would earn $62,889, exceeding the interest savings in all three loan scenarios. Repaying the mortgage not only saves interest but also releases extra funds that could be invested at the same return rate.

Investments carry different risk levels. Choosing to invest instead of paying off a mortgage early comes with the risk of losing some or all of the invested money, and the mortgage payments would still be due. Even though the stock market can deliver substantial returns, it also carries the possibility of significant losses. Investors need to understand that achieving a 10% investment gain may be challenging after considering fees, taxes, and inflation. Having realistic expectations is vital when estimating potential market earnings.

In conclusion, when determining whether to pay off a mortgage early or invest the money, various factors need to be evaluated. These include the interest rate, remaining balance, and potential interest savings. Using a mortgage loan calculator can help break down the amortization schedule. Moreover, homeowners should remember that mortgage interest is often tax-deductible, which can decrease taxable income. Consultation with a financial planner and tax advisor is recommended to effectively assess personal circumstances and objectives. Their expert advice can offer valuable insights into making an informed decision.


Other articles